Research Outcomes

Now that I have completed my dissertation i have come to some interesting conclusions. I thought I would recap my research process and present my research findings:

This study set out to answer the questions “how do zines create a sense of local community within the context of Dunedin, New Zealand?”

To discover the answer to this question I selected four case study Dunedin zines: Marrow Magazine, DUDzine, The Envoy from Bedlam and Permanent Vacation. I interviewed the editors of these zines about their zines and their connections to different communities related to their zines, motivations for starting their zines, and their opinions on both online and printed media. The findings of this study suggest that firstly sense of community is not something that can be created, but it can be encouraged. This study also indicates that zines can increase a sense of local community in Dunedin, and this can be enhanced by a number of factors:

  1. The physical nature of a printed zine- all editors had a preference for paper zines as they appeared to facilitate communication with their readers on a more personal and direct level.
  2. The connection with readers though supplementary blogs or other online media- online components helped the editors strengthen the connection between their community of interest and the local community
  3. Collaborative production and publishing efforts relating to the local community’s culture- The two zines that indicated the strongest connection to the local Dunedin community both had a major focus on collaboration from the Dunedin locals. This content was mainly artistic content, relating to the Dunedin’s artistic culture. Furthermore, this artistic focus may be more open for a community gathering in a local environment as opposed to personal or existential themes.
  4. Alternative spaces and cultural establishments that reinforce their identity as creative outsiders- One of the zines showed a particular connection and support for local cultural or ‘alternative’ establishments such as Modaks cafe, Mint DVD rental, or Re:Fuel Bar and Cafe. This connection could be largely due to the fact that they identify with these particular places.
  5. The size and plan of the civic space in which the zine is published and distributed- Dunedin has a centralised business and cultural district, therefore functions more as a small town than a sprawling city, even though it has the population of a city. Research shows that small towns are more likely to allow members to have a sense of local community (Prezza and Constantini 191).
  6. Sense of community is not an aspiration for all people; zines can validate and strengthen the position of the outsider- One of the editors positioned himself outside any community, with his zine announcing and celebrating the status of the outsider.

Marrow Magazine

Marrow Magazine is a monthly zine that has been circulating in Dunedin since 2010. It covers and includes a range of local literature, poetry, art, design, craft and other creative work. Marrow can be picked up for free around Dunedin in cafes, on campus, and in music shops. They have around 20 contributors each month and all contributors are volunteers. Take a look at the post I wrote about Marrow back in May for more information.

I interviewed both of the editors of Marrow Magazine as one of the case studies for my dissertation. Click the link below to read the interview transcript:

Transcript for interview with Marrow Magazine

Permanent Vacation

Permanent Vacation is a zine containing a mix of photos, drawings, articles, and stories from around the world, all focusing on the theme of “anywhere but here.” It has a glossy, beautifully designed aesthetic, crossed with some cut-and-paste and hand-drawn elements. The zine has one editor/ designer, Kerry Ann Lee, along with 26 of her friends from around the world as collaborators. Permanent Vacation is sold at the Dunedin Public Art Gallery and is also sold in independent zine and bookstores in Wellington, Auckland, Australia, America, and Germany.

Permanent Vacation was one of the case study zines in my dissertation. I interviewed Kerry Ann in regards to her involvement in this zine and also others she has published over the last fourteen years, such as Help My Snowman’s Burning. Click the link below to read this transcript (this transcript contains a mix of both direct quotes and my own notes from the interview):

Permanent Vacation Interview Transcript

Five Card Stories

My supervisor, Mark McGuire, has made a recent post about Five Card Stories on Flickr. This is a fun exercise in which five Flickr photos are drawn at random and then it is up to you to link these photos into some sort of story. Check out some examples here.

I had a go at this myself and this is how it turned out:


Five Card Story: Little Girl’s Journey

a Five Card Flickr story created by jessnz2


flickr photo by Serenae


flickr photo by hummingcrow


flickr photo by bionicteaching


flickr photo by Serenae


flickr photo by Serenae

In an old farmhouse

there lived a lonely little girl

one day she went for a walk down a long road

gathering beautiful flowers along the way

she gave them to another little girl and made her smile!


eBooks

"Diving into Digital Books 2" by lib-girl on Flickr

My supervisor, Mark McGuire, has written a recent blog post on the subject of the ebook. He was writing this post in response to an article on salon.com called Why the Book’s Future Never Happened. This article questions why the hypertext novel has not taken over the traditional book. This links quite closely to my research on zines: While the blog functions in a similar way to the zine (in that it allows people to to self-publish and express their opinions unrestricted and for a very low cost) it is interesting that the zine in its paper form is still preferred in the zine world. Research has shown that communication on a very personal level and also the formation of a community are both important reasons for creating a zine. The findings of my research suggests that the paper medium may facilitate a closer and more personal relationship between the reader and writer. The editors of the four case study zines in my research all believed that they could reach people on a personal level through having a zine in paper medium and distributing it in the “real world” as opposed to online. The editors also all talked about the ‘personal’ or special’ characteristics of paper that the Internet does not have. These characteristics create a much closer relationship between the reader and writer.

So while I am not entirely sure about the future of the book, it seems that zines at least will remain in paper form for a long time to come as it helps to form and strengthen zine communities and relationships between zine editors and their readers.

DONE!

Photo courtesy of Kazeeee on Flickr

My dissertation is done and dusted! Two days ago I printed, bound and handed it in (after an all-nighter in the design department might I add). I am very pleased!

Even though I have finished, I thought I would still upload the remaining interview transcripts from my zine case studies, so that anyone who is interested may read them. I will be uploading these soon!

 

The Envoy from Bedlam

The deadline for this dissertation is fast approaching! With one week to go I am really feeling the pressure!! However it is slowly but surely coming together which is nice!

This week I thought I would upload the transcript from my interview with the editor of the Dunedin zine, The Envoy from Bedlam. This zine focusses on metaphysical and existential issues. The editor has strong beliefs that the media is “banal”, “superficial” and suppressing a lot of important information. This zine is his outlet for his frustrations at the media. He also hopes that through reading his zine, humanity might “evolve”. The one editor writes the majority of the articles himself but sometimes supplements these with articles he has read on the internet (he always references them). Even though the zine is only distributed in Dunedin, it does not have any particular Dunedin or New Zealand themes, as the editor explained has more of an interest in global issues.

I interviewed the editor of The Envoy from Bedlam as one of my Dunedin zine case studies. Click the link below to download the transcript of the interview:

The Envoy from Bedlam Interview Transcript

Facebook: How much are we sharing?

Facebook (image from www.yourbdnews.com)

My supervisor, Mark McGuire, made a recent blog post about social networking sites such as Facebook. Facebook has been in the media a lot lately because of its new, controversial changes. Among these changes is the ‘timeline’ which essentially creates an autobiography of users’ lives, storing and sharing every photo, status update, and application they have used, viewed or uploaded to the site. The other controversial function is ‘Ticker’, which automatically posts to the site users’ activity on certain applications, such as watching a video on Netflix or listening to a song on Spotify. This is being referred to as ‘frictionless sharing,’ however there have been many complaints that this a breach of privacy. Below is an excerpt from Steven Levy’s recent article on Wired:

 ”All those activities people perform with these apps–listening to a Bjork tune, reading about same-sex marriage laws, cooking Arroz con Pollo, running four miles, donating to Amnesty International–will be stored permanently and made accessible (if the user allows it) on a greatly enhanced profile page that will essentially become a remote-control autobiography”

Personally, I find this all a bit creepy. I like to have control of what I share online, and I certainly don’t like the idea of Facebook tracking my every move. Apparently users are given the option to opt out of Facebook instantly sharing this information, but an article on the news site, Stuff, suggests otherwise. I guess I will just have to wait until I have used these new features myself before I can judge!

DUDzine

DUDzine is one of the four Dunedin zines I have conducted a case study on for my dissertation. It is a zine put out by the Dunedin Comic Collective in between the release of each of their comic magazines, DUD. The zine is a place for comic artists in Dunedin to share their work, and because it is not the main publication (DUD), it can contain work of any standard – the zine has no rules. The editor explained that because the zine has no formal conventions to stick to, it means that anyone can have their work printed, which will hopefully encourage them to keep on creating more work.

I interviewed the main editor, Spencer Hall, to find out his motivations for starting the zine, the production and distribution processes behind it, his use of the internet, and also whether the zine allows him to feel a sense of belonging to any form of community.

Below is the transcript for the interview. It contains direct quotes that I saw as important, the rest is in note form.

Click here to download the transcript: DUDzine interview transcript

 

Sir Ken Robinson: Bring on the Learning Revolution! (TED Talk)

Learning through creativity - image by pollyalida (Flickr)

My surpervisor, Mark McGuire, made a recent blog post on Ken Robinson’s 2010 TED talk. This talk highlighted the fact that many people go through life not knowing their true talents, mostly because of education. He explains this in the following quote:

“Education in a way dislocates people from their natural talents. And human resources are like natural resources they are often buried deep. You have to go looking for them, they are not lying around on the surface. You have to create the circumstances where they show themselves.”

Education is apparently being reformed at present, but Robinson believes this is just “improving a broken model.” There needs to be a real revolution and innovation around education. Robinson points out that the current education system enthralls people to certain ideas that we take as normal and given, however old they may be.

One current idea humanity is stuck on is linearity, that life is a linear process. However we need to move from this state of linearity and conformity to a model of customisation. Customising for the individual person being taught. The education system needs to be reinvented to allow all people to find their talents, not stifling them because of what may seem the norm. People should be helped to discover their passion.

This actually made me think about my own tertiary education. Doing a Design Studies major at my university has taught me to think in ways I would not have had the chance to learn about in other courses. Design Studies teaches people to take problems and look at them from all angles to come up with solutions that are really radical and functional. Many clever thinkers and, for want of a better word, innovators have come out of this course. It seems unfortunate that the University is trying to slowly close down this Department- they clearly do not see its value. The university is stifling one of its most creative courses in favour of the more academic courses. Hopefully this education revolution occurs soon!